On June 1, 2018, residents of Basin gathered to celebrate a remarkable milestone: the Big Horn County Courthouse officially turned 100 years old. With an old-fashioned ice cream social, courthouse tours, live music by the Wyoming Fiddlers, and a local history presentation from historian Jeanie Cook, the event honored one of the most enduring civic landmarks in the Big Horn Basin.
Completed in 1918, the Big Horn County Courthouse has now stood for well over a century, a stately reminder that even in one of Wyoming’s roughest frontier chapters, the rule of law ultimately took root.
With its grand columns and enduring architecture, the courthouse symbolized stability, civic pride, and a maturing county moving beyond the volatile days of territorial justice and frontier uncertainty.
Before the Current Courthouse: Crime, Isolation, and Frontier Justice
Not long before the elegant courthouse opened its doors, Big Horn County’s legal system faced the challenges of serving justice in what could still have been considered a frontier community.
According to Northern Wyoming News’ “Murder and Mob Law in the Big Horn Basin” historical series by John Bernhisel (Dec. 11, 2025), one of the county’s most haunting early cases began in late summer 1901 near Thermopolis, when J.P. Walters confronted Agnes Hoover after she repeatedly rejected his marriage proposals.
Walters shot and killed Hoover in front of her young son, Alfred, before attempting to take his own life. Sheriff A.S. Garland had to ride approximately 70 miles from Basin to investigate and bring Walters back to the county jail, a vivid example of the immense challenges law enforcement faced before modern infrastructure or a permanent courthouse existed.
Initially, Walters was quickly convicted and scheduled for execution, but appeals to the Wyoming Supreme Court delayed the sentence as attorneys argued insanity brought on by obsession.
At nearly the same time, another grisly case erupted west of Ten Sleep on Broken Back Creek. Tom Gorman, a successful cattleman, disappeared. Neighbors later discovered his partially burned and dismembered body in a shallow grave. Suspicion centered on his younger brother Jim Gorman and Tom’s wife Maggie.
Suddenly, Big Horn County was housing two notorious murder suspects in Basin’s early jail system, while public outrage surged and rumors of mob violence spread.
Sheriff Garland’s Defining Moment
Caught between public fury and legal responsibility, Sheriff Garland became one of the county’s earliest defenders of due process.
In an era when lynching was still considered swift justice by some frontier communities, Garland’s efforts to protect prisoners and preserve lawful trials helped shape Big Horn County’s legal identity.
His work represented a pivotal shift: justice would be determined by courts, not crowds.
That philosophy would later be embodied in the construction of the permanent courthouse completed in 1918.
The Courthouse as a Symbol of a New Era
When the Big Horn County Courthouse opened, it was far more than a government building. It was a statement that Big Horn County had entered a new chapter, one defined by civic structure, legal permanence, and institutional order.
For more than 100 years, the courthouse has witnessed:
- Major criminal proceedings
- Land and water disputes
- Economic development
- Community milestones
- The everyday workings of local government
Its walls stand as a symbol of Wyoming’s transition from frontier uncertainty to established governance.
The Human Legacy Behind the Headlines
The Hoover family story did not end in tragedy alone.
Stella Hoover eventually married, raised three children, and died in Los Angeles in 1947. Frederick Hoover served in World War I and returned home a decorated veteran. Alfred Hoover, who witnessed his mother’s murder, remained close to his family throughout his life.
These lives, and countless others shaped by Big Horn County’s earliest days, are woven into the broader story of the courthouse.
Check Out These Bighorn Basin Businesses
More Than a Building
Today, more than a century after its completion and years after its June 1, 2018 centennial celebration, the Big Horn County Courthouse remains one of Basin’s defining landmarks.
It is a place where law replaced vigilantism, where frontier hardship gave way to public institutions, and where the stories of Wyoming’s earliest settlers continue to echo.
From the days of sheriffs riding horseback across vast distances to modern county government, the Big Horn County Courthouse stands not simply as a building, but as a monument to justice, resilience, and the enduring history of the Big Horn Basin.
Subscribe to stay up to date with the latest from Bighorn Basin Explorer
Bighorn Basin Explorer 
Leave a comment